Back in November of last year, “I wrote about a ridiculous law”:2 that was being proposed in Westchester County. The law would require firewalls to be established on all business networks that make use of Wi-Fi technologies, in an attempt to curb identity theft. At the time, I tried to contact the County Executive, since NYCwireless clearly had something to add to any debate that was ongoing. Unfortunately, they were unreachable (a bad trait for any public official) and did not return any calls.
Well, it seems that against all better judgement, “the proposed legislation is now law”:1, and will take effect in six months.
I had voiced some “serious criticism”:2 for the law, which overall creates a false sense of security. County Executive Andrew Spano clearly hasn’t been listening to any of the people who have been trying to help inform him:
bq. “There are many unsecured wireless networks out there, and any malicious individual with even minimal technical competence would have no trouble accessing information that should be kept confidential,” Spano said. “It would be nice if these businesses took the necessary steps on their own to ensure their networks were kept secure, but the sad fact is that many don’t.”
The law, as written, won’t do anything to help deter serious identity theft crimes. The administration’s own people even acknowledge that:
bq. Andrew Neuman, a senior assistant to Spano, said, “We know this is not a silver bullet. But deterring amateur hackers from the easiest targets is a step in the right direction.”
Deterring amateur hackers isn’t a step in *any* direction. As I previously stated, amateur hackers aren’t the people you should be afraid of, nor are they the ones causing most of the identity theft damage. Its the big guys, who know a hell of a lot more than most other people do, and will be able to easily circumvent the Administration’s regulated “protections”.
[1]http://www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/newyork/ny-bc-ny–wirelesssecurity0420apr20,0,2365284.story?coll=ny-region-apnewyork
[2]http://www.wirelesscommunity.info/2005/11/08/westchester-county-law-requiring-secured-wi-fi-networks/
Filed under: News, Policy